M
case study
International -
Rebuilding Downtown Beirut
“Paris of the Middle East”
Beirut’s city centre is now mostly rebuilt. A quarter century after it was destroyed during the Lebanese civil war, the area is now a polished mix of restored buildings, ancient ruins and glass towers. But a place that once drew all of Lebanon’s diverse people to its souks, cafes, cinemas and hotels is a somewhat rootless zone of empty luxury stores and unoccupied apartments. Rebuilt as a destination for international money and tourists, it is no longer the heart of Beirut but a very costly monument to vanity and self-delusion.
The city suffers from the deep failures of governance that afflict the whole country. Public transport is almost non-existent, there is no social housing, a half comfortable life relies on generators and private tankers to bring in water and more people look to confessional groups for help than to the moribund municipal government. The city often ranks low in international liveability surveys, even falling behind its Middle Eastern neighbours like Amman and Cairo.
LEBANON
3,500,000 Million inhabitants
1975
$ 15,000,000,000 in damage
$ 5,000,000,000to infrastructure alone
15 YEARS OF CIVIL WAR
1990
The private company that runs the downtown 93 ha (230 acres)allocated for development, including 22 ha (54 acres) of retained, public or religious property
Undermined the public good, violated the constitution, demolished too many buildings & acted only in the interest of international investors, according to its critics.
Solidere: The Backlash
-
Beirut Central District (BCD) is now the site of impeccably restored buildings and modern glass towers = heritage exists in the very fabric of cities
-
Erased 80 % of Beirut’s architectural heritage.Solidere actually demolished many salvageable buildings in an attempt to erase the memories of war and to enable it to raise densities by building modern towers.
-
30 % of original owners kept their properties
-
Enclave = “does not feel Lebanese anymore
-
Vulnerable to external shocks
-
Focusing purely on tourism = create a risk of business drying up
-
Become a playground for “star architects” to create their luxurious “totem
-
Public space is exclusive
-
The silence shaped Beirut’s built environment.
Before
After
The Beirut Souks
The current souk area was planned as the city centre’s future retail and commercial hub. Most of the stores that occupy the Beirut Souks have no connection to the city.
1960s
2005
Martyrs' Square
known as the Bourj was the most important space in downtown Beirut before the war. The city lost its pre-eminent public space and one of the most important places for political and social expression. The square that now came into sight was almost unrecognizable replaced with a temporary car park.
Lessons for Marawi from what happened in Beirut
-
Reconstruction in Marawi must be focused on local economic and social needs rather than those of globalised capitalism.
-
Must be on re-developing a city centre in Marawi that is lively, inclusive and as important to city residents as it is to investors and tourists
-
Ownership models should not be seriously disrupted
-
Focus on restoration of its historic centre not just as a tourist destination but also as a living city
-
Finding appropriate memorials after conflict can be a struggle
Local -
Zamboanga Post-Conflict Community Engagement
“City of Flowers”
“Asia’s Latin City.”
Two years after the outbreak of what has been called the “Zamboanga Siege,” more than 17,000 internally displaced persons (IDPs) remain in transitional sites, while another 7, 719 are home-based IDPs, i.e., those hosted by relatives and friends or renting temporary homes.
Zamboanga City is a highly urbanized city and the sixth most populous city in the Philippines (as of 2010). Also the third largest city by land area, it is the commercial and industrial center of the Zamboanga Peninsula, which is located in Western Mindanao, south of the Philippines. The city is situated at the southern tip of the province of Zamboanga del Sur.
The siege in Zamboanga City started on Sept. 9, 2013 with the eruption of fighting between a faction of the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) and Philippine government forces. After more than a week of sporadic fighting, the government declared the end of major security operations on September 28, 2013.
Immediate results of the siege were some 10,000 houses destroyed in five barangays and 118,000 IDPs at the peak of displacement. Displaced people sought temporary shelter in the Joaquin F. Enriquez Jr. Sports Complex (JFEJSC, the city grandstand), evacuation centers in schools, and homes of relatives and friends.
Transitory Sites
-
“Why build our houses in another place? Why not allow us to go back to our places of origin?”
-
Worsened their trauma and have created bigger problems.
-
The Badjao are uncomfortable with the use of corrugated iron sheets for roofing, as they believe that ancestors and spirits dwell in their houses.
Buggoc Site
-
Sheltered in the 200 single-detached housing units of the water village at the Buggoc.
-
Badjaos are now able to go back to their main source of income, which is fishing. Some are now engaged selling their catch at the public market​